Six Outstanding Substitutes for Cream Cheese

Although you may believe that the creamy, savory spread you like on your bagel every morning is essential, it’s useful to know what substitutes you may use in a pinch if your supply of cream cheese runs out.

There are many of alternatives to cream cheese that work just as well and yield comparable results, whether you’re looking for a new bagel topper, a creamy element for dips and sauces, a thickener for cake frosting, or a rich, salty touch to savory dishes like stuffed chicken and mashed potatoes.

Furthermore, there are a number of healthier cream cheese substitutes that have higher protein and calcium contents and lower fat content. Try experimenting with different possibilities if you’re looking for nutrient-dense ones that nevertheless have excellent flavor and texture. Check out our list of six excellent cream cheese alternatives to make sure you never have to give up your favorite creamy spread again.

1. Mascarpone

Mascarpone cheese, also known as triple cream cheese, is a great alternative to cream cheese in a variety of culinary applications because it has a flavor that is very similar to cream cheese but with a creamier texture. Mascarpone cheese has double the fat level of cream cheese, but it tastes great and is high in calcium, so it’s a great alternative for people looking for something a little more decadent.

It’s excellent as a frosting for cakes and cupcakes and tastes great as a topping for fresh fruit. Mascarpone’s smooth texture and high butterfat content make it suitable for a variety of uses, including thickening soups, enhancing pasta sauces, and serving as a dip or spread on bagels.

2. Neufchatel

Neufchatel is a fantastic flavor and texture substitute for cream cheese. With only one-third the fat of cream cheese, this semi-soft cow’s milk cheese tastes sharp and nutty, making it a healthier choice.

Neufchatel is a great addition to any dish calling for reduced-fat cream cheese, like mashed potatoes, bagel spreads, or cake frosting. Try adding a small amount of butter to the Neufchatel to get a more accurate representation of the rich, creamy texture of cream cheese.

3. Ricotta

Compared to cream cheese, ricotta has a grainier texture and a milder sweetness, yet it works well in baked goods. Ricotta is a great alternative to cream cheese when making baked products like cheesecake or cake frosting that require the creamy texture of cream cheese. A tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice might assist produce the desired tanginess because of its softer acidity and slightly drier texture.

4. Greek Yogurt

For a nutritious, protein-rich alternative, Greek yogurt is an excellent substitute for cream cheese. You can even make Greek yogurt into cream cheese by placing one cup of it in a cheesecloth over a strainer set on a bowl and letting it drain for 8-12 hours.

This process removes the whey, leaving you with a thick, creamy substitute. Although strained Greek yogurt is not as creamy as traditional cream cheese, it performs wonderfully in frostings and baked goods when sweetened with a bit of honey or maple syrup, and it adds a touch of richness to savory dishes too.

5. Hummus

For a completely dairy-free option, hummus proves to be an unexpectedly excellent replacement for cream cheese, thanks to its smooth texture and rich, tangy taste. Despite its distinct flavor compared to cream cheese, hummus serves as a nutritious alternative for spreading on bagels, creating creamy dips for veggies or chips, and even adding a savory twist to cheesecake.

6. Sour Cream

To infuse your dips and sauces with a zestier taste, grab some sour cream. Its tart flavor and rich texture will enhance any dip or sauce with a delicate tang, and it can also be used as a substitute in some cake recipes, provided you add extra flour to achieve a firmer consistency.

Read Also: Five Alternatives to Coconut Milk